Who I Would Have Picked for the 2019 Baseball Hall of Fame Inductees

Realistically, not much happens in the baseball offseason. A few players find new homes and call movers to relocate before spring training, and others hit the golf courses. For players who have been retired from the game for at least five years, they patiently wait for “the call”: The call from the Baseball Hall of Fame.

I’ve been known to do a lot of yelling about the results, because that’s what I do. But in the past few years, I’ve agreed with who was inducted. The voting is done by the Baseball Writers’ Association of America, and they definitely don’t ask for my opinion on any of this, but I’m giving it anyway.

So enjoy.

The 2019 Baseball Hall of Fame inductees are…

  • Mariano Rivera (100.0% of the vote, first year on the ballot)
  • Edgar Martinez (85.4%, tenth year)
  • Roy Halladay (85.4%, first year)
  • Mike Mussina (76.7%, sixth year)

In order to be inducted, players must be retired for at least five seasons and receive 75% of the overall vote. Players are taken off the ballots after 10 years and if they fail to receive 5% of the votes.

I agree with the BBWAA’s choices. Rivera was a shoo-in, especially after Trevor Hoffman was inducted last year. I mean, the dude had a 0.70 ERA in the playoffs. I don’t think anyone is going to tell you that Rivera isn’t a Hall of Famer; he was the first ever unanimous inductee. Martinez was a DH who played his entire career with the Seattle Mariners. He’s technically the second player in the HOF who played the majority of his games as a DH; Frank Thomas was elected in 2014. As for Roy Halladay, let me just sit here and sob uncontrollably for Doc. He passed away in November 2017 in a plane crash in the Gulf of Mexico. I grew up watching him and Rivera the most because they played in the AL East. His death still makes me so sad but I’m so glad he made it into the HOF. Mussina was sort of before my time, as his last season was in 2008, but I knew he played for the Yankees and was really good. Plus he was often called “The Moose.”

Do we want to have the Barry Bonds/Roger Clemens/Sammy Sosa discussion? My thoughts on them haven’t changed at all. This year, Clemens came in sixth with 59.5%, Bonds in seventh at 59.1%, and Sosa was 18th with 8.5%. The gruesome threesome are all on their seventh year of eligibility, and I don’t think anything will happen until their last year, when it might be close. Might.

Let’s do some math!

  • Roger Clemens: 59.5% (2019) vs. 57.3% (2018) = 2.2%
  • Barry Bonds: 59.1% (2019) vs. 56.4% (2018) = 2.7%
  • Sammy Sosa: 8.5% (2019) vs. 7.8% (2018) = 0.7%

If they keep getting that increase in percentages for the last three years, they won’t make it. That’s why I think it’ll be close, but I don’t think they want to risk putting them in the hall. And if for some reason they end up in there, somewhere it has to acknowledge their numbers are tainted. Just has to. Their numbers don’t stand up to the clean ones that are in there. Call me old fashioned, but I’m against it.

Someone else who is still hanging around on the outside looking in is Curt Schilling. He came in fifth with 60.9% of votes, and although he didn’t take steroids, he’s still connected in a weird way since he spoke in front of Congress and has just been problematic over the past few years.

Manny Ramirez is on year three, and he received 22.8% of the votes and came in 11th. Part of me feels sympathetic because he played on the Sox—I guess the same could be said of Schilling—but he did get suspended for 50 games for violating MLB’s drug policy. BY TAKING A WOMEN’S FERTILITY DRUG TO HIDE HIS STEROIDS. So.

Some fan favorites who won’t be joining us in the future:

  • Roy Oswalt
  • Placido Polanco
  • Ted Lilly
  • Travis Hafner
  • Kevin Youkilis
  • Rick Ankiel
  • Vernon Wells
  • Derek Lowe
  • Jason Bay

These fine folks received 0.0% of the votes, although Oswalt received four and Polanco received two. I so miss Travis Hafner and Jason Bay. And Youk. I mean, he’s the Greek God of Walks. And don’t forget about Rick Ankiel. Surprised the man is still standing.

So if I had a ballot, which would be a risky thing for the BBWAA to give me, I’d vote for:

  1. Mariano Rivera
  2. Edgar Martinez
  3. Roy Halladay
  4. Todd Helton
  5. Andy Pettitte
  6. Mike Mussina
  7. Kevin Youkilis
  8. Jason Bay
  9. Placido Polanco
  10. Michael Young

I honestly don’t think that Jason Bay is HOF material; I just really, really liked him when he played for the Sox. And don’t forget about that time the Colorado Rockies gave Todd Helton a horse for his retirement.

Here’s the list of players. Who would be on your ballot?


  1. You would vote for Polanco?? Is that just a random fandom thing? I was shocked he got 2 real votes. I’m sad Vernon Wells didn’t get any – I wore #10 as a kid for 3 years because of him.

    I have no clue what my opinion is on Bonds and Clemens. Steroids didn’t help Bonds hit a ball, but they did allow him to play longer and never really regress. I mean, (by my quick math) he hit 317 home runs after he turned 35. That’s insane. Clemens was with the Blue Jays in ’97 and ’98 and won the Cy Young both years. Those were my first years as a fan. Jose Canseco was on the ’98 team, so there was just a whole bunch of nefarious things going on while I tried to teach myself which number on the TV screen was for balls and which was for strikes.

    This comment is too long but my ballot would be:
    1. Halladay – Most of his games were about 2 hours 10 min., loved it
    2. Rivera – So intimidating
    3. Martinez – I like how Safeco Field has a restaurant called Edgar’s
    4. Mussina – Always killed the Jays when he was with the Orioles
    5. Larry Walker – Canadian, 3 batting titles after age of 30, I don’t care that he played at Coors Field, he also played half his games on the road
    6. Curt Schilling – I’ll always love the bloody sock game even if it might’ve been embellished
    7. Fred McGriff
    8. Manny Ramirez – He made me like the Red Sox in 2004
    9. Vernon Wells (sentimental pick)
    10. Juan Pierre (sentimental pick)

    Liked by 2 people

    • Yeah, I remember when he used to play for the Tigers and I always liked him. I’m surprised Wells didn’t at least get a few.

      I agree with you about steroids helping Bonds play longer. That’s how he was able to rack up all of those homeruns. If he hadn’t taken anything and played a normal length of a career, he wouldn’t have the numbers he has. Oh jeez, Jose Canseco. He’s a fun one. Did you know that umps give the ball/strike count back to the pitcher backwards? Like they’ll hold up the count on their fingers and it’s strikes/balls instead. When I did the book in high school, it always threw me off.

      I had put Ramirez on my list and then took him off because of the 50 game suspension and the whole steroids/women’s hormones thing. But that wasn’t when he was with the Sox, sooo. I think as he gets further into the ten years on the ballot, I think there will be some chatter about him.

      Liked by 1 person

      • I hate when umpires give the count backwards! As a former child pitcher (for softball, but it still counts), the umpire always held it up backwards, so I would just ignore him and memorize the count myself. Umpires are too defiant to be pitcher-friendly.

        I hope the writers don’t hold the “Manny Being Manny” antics against him, in addition to the steroids. I can see them trying to take the high ground and say he wasn’t professional enough.

        Liked by 2 people

  2. Hey! I’m not really sure what I’ve been doing all this time but oh well, I’m finally ready to comment on your HOF post. Of course, I guess I’ve been hibernating. Also, I’ve been preparing my own post and so that typically keeps me from reading others’ posts so that my original ideas are just that, my own originals. Too late for that now since I don’t know what I’m doing with that post. (I’ll get to it someday)

    I was really happy with the BBWAA voting this year for the most part. I have tons of issues with the entire process but that’s for my own column.

    I would have voted for all 4 dudes that made it, plus many others. Curt Schilling is a no-brainer. He could, should, and will get in soon. Who cares about his political views? If we cared about that, then we would all hate 50% of Hall of Famers, right? Bottom line, did a player deserve it? Was he one of the best baseball players ever?

    1. Mariano Rivera – Best closer ever
    2. Roy Halladay – When I write Roy I always think of “ROY” (Rookie of the Year abbreviation)
    3. Edgar Martinez – Best DH ever
    4. Mike Mussina – the more I study his numbers, I think, Wow! Moose was fantastic.
    5. Curt Schilling – A good long career. One of the most clutch postseason starters ever
    6. Manny Ramirez – one of the greatest right-handed hitters of all time.
    7. Barry Bonds – All-time HR king. Never caught with a dirty PED test anyway, so the writers are keeping out the greatest hitter ever because of what exactly?…….that they ASSUME he did steroids?….or that he is/was a pompous jerk?
    8. Roger Clemens – I absolutely hate Roger Clemens. But who cares what I think about a guy? Was he one of the greatest pitchers ever? Yes.

    That’s it for now. I need to do more research on guys like Todd Helton, Gary Sheffield, and Larry Walker.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.